Difference between revisions of "The BEST Headset"
(→Why not a Chris King headset?) |
(→What is so great about the Cane Creek S-3?) |
||
| Line 16: | Line 16: | ||
The cheaper option to the [http://www.canecreek.com/s-8.html Cane Creek S-8], the [http://www.canecreek.com/s-3.html Cane Creek S-3] is about the greatest value and performer on the market. | The cheaper option to the [http://www.canecreek.com/s-8.html Cane Creek S-8], the [http://www.canecreek.com/s-3.html Cane Creek S-3] is about the greatest value and performer on the market. | ||
| − | First, the price. This headset is commonly available for around $26, 1/5 the cost of a Chris King headset. An S-8 will set you back around $55, twice the cost. | + | *First, the price. This headset is commonly available for around $26, 1/5 the cost of a Chris King headset. An S-8 will set you back around $55, twice the cost. |
| − | Second, the performance. This headset like the King, use quality sealed cartridge bearings to function, but rather than use an o-ring, the cane creek (like many other competitors) use a compression ring to hold the steerer in line with the headset. This design holds solid and does not move like the King design. The increase in performance is noticable. | + | *Second, the performance. This headset like the King, use quality sealed cartridge bearings to function, but rather than use an o-ring, the cane creek (like many other competitors) use a compression ring to hold the steerer in line with the headset. This design holds solid and does not move like the King design. The increase in performance is noticable. |
These two points make the Cane Creek a hands down winner for best headset. | These two points make the Cane Creek a hands down winner for best headset. | ||
Revision as of 00:33, 12 December 2006
Contents
The Best
The finest, greatest performing headset that I have ever owned is also one of the best values, the Cane Creek S-3. Commonly available for around $30.
Why not a Chris King headset?
Back in the day of threaded 1" steerers, only two real performance options existed for bicycles, the Campagnolo Record HS-01OR Headset or the Chris King Two Nut headset. Both were fantastic options for both on and off road.
Then came oversized threadless steerers and new developements. Chris King was first to the punch and arguably holds a patent on the design, but slowly the others followed and improved their designs. For many years, the Chris King NoThreadset headset was the only quality choice available, but recently things have changed.
The real Achiles Heal of the Chris King design is the way that the top plate is held concentric to the steerer tube. An o-ring is used to hold the top plate centered. The problem with this design is that when strong enough forces are introduced to the fork, the o-ring gives a little and the steerer is pushed off center of the headset. Many people will see wear marks on their aluminium steerers and a wear pattern on the taper of the base and top plate. Wear will also be noticable between the top plate and the first spacer or stem if the delrin shim is not in place (you were wondering what it was for?).
One possible argument for this is that the o-ring acts almost like a shock absorber for the bearings, transfering wear to more cheaply replaced parts. I don't buy it thought.
Keep in mind that I have a lot of respect for what King has done for cycleing and the quality and products that he has brought to market. I just wish that the design for the headset gets fixed.
What is so great about the Cane Creek S-3?
The cheaper option to the Cane Creek S-8, the Cane Creek S-3 is about the greatest value and performer on the market.
- First, the price. This headset is commonly available for around $26, 1/5 the cost of a Chris King headset. An S-8 will set you back around $55, twice the cost.
- Second, the performance. This headset like the King, use quality sealed cartridge bearings to function, but rather than use an o-ring, the cane creek (like many other competitors) use a compression ring to hold the steerer in line with the headset. This design holds solid and does not move like the King design. The increase in performance is noticable.
These two points make the Cane Creek a hands down winner for best headset.
Addition reasons for the S-3's rule
A recent problem experience by the off road cyclist is that frame and fork manufactures are not on the same page all the time and forks will sometimes hit the down tube when spun in a crash. This damages the fork, usually, and sometimes the frame.
Cane Creek has recently released the S-3 Plus 5, The same design as the S-3, but with 5mm more lower stack height to give the forks more clearance. Chris King has done nothing about this problem.
